The Pizza Shoppe

Reviews

• Shaun W.

  star star star star star 11 June 2026

  This is our favorite pizza in town. We've lived in E Patchogue for 5 years and we have tried all the local pizzerias. They are generous with the toppings, the cheese is not greasy and they have sesame crust! We are regulars and have always been treated very courteously by the staff. The zeppolis are delicious, too. We are happy for them, but hate when they go on vacation and we have to try another shop. It never measures up. I make my own salad because theirs is just cucumbers, olives and tomatoes & I like a lot of veggies in my salad. We always order ahead, get extra sauce & reheat on our pizza stone! They are respectful of my food allergy. We highly recommend!

• Lilli M.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 9 June 2026

  This review is strictly for lack of customer service - their food is pretty good however the lady who works there is awful!
  
  My daughter ordered two gyros, a pasta and a salad to be delivered; I observed her place the order.  The order was delivered and only 1 gyro was with the order; she called back and explained a gyro was missing and the woman began to yell at her that she only paid for one gyro; no apology for missing the gyro in the order.  It got to the point where my daughter (17) was becoming upset on the phone at which point - I got involved explained she had ordered two and only 1 was delivered.  The woman said we were not charge and I asked them for her to itemize the bill for me; she told me she doesn't know the prices off the top of her head she just pushes buttons on the register - but if I wanted it I needed to pay for it.  
  
  She was very aggressive on the phone - I asked her if this is how she spoke to all customers and suggested that because she made the error she really should not charge us; especially since we would be delayed further.
  
  She told me I was the one arguing with her and the only way we were getting the gyro was if we paid for it...
  
  WOW!  Won't be giving them our business ever again.

• Julie F.

  star star star star_border star_border 5 June 2026

  Not as good as it used to be.. been a customer for years there's always that one guy with a really bad attitude.. there pizza now always taste uncooked

• Richard G.

  star star star star_border star_border 24 May 2026

  Used to love going to this place It always had fresh food never had any problems this past year the times we have gone it has seriously gone downhill. Very disappointing sometimes they deliver sometimes they don't. The pizza never used to be soggy now it seems like it always is.

• Cheryl M.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 19 May 2026

  I ordered a plain large pie and Large Italian salad from here with delivery. It took 40+ minutes to arrive, and worse, the pizza was horrible. It was super greasy, cheese seemed to be just globbed on and unevenly distributed, the crust sloppy and tasteless, and overall, just a bland pizza. As for the salad, some romaine, cucumbers and tomatoes with cheap can Olives for $7.  I shouldn't just bought the ingredients myself. Not worth the $25, the wait, or the calories.  I used to eat here all the time and it was always standard decent reliably good. Definitely won't be anymore.